Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance Review 2024

Plymouth Rock is awaiting a NerdWallet star rating to be determined later this year, and the ratings are done by the editorial team of NerdWallet. They consider consumer experience, complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, and financial strength ratings. Founded in 1982, Plymouth Rock Assurance is a small company that provides auto insurance policies in only six states, including Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania.

Plymouth Rock also offers various other insurance options such as homeowners, renters, umbrella, term life, flood, and pet insurance. Policies can be acquired online, through an agent, or over the phone. Additionally, Plymouth Rock auto insurance can be purchased from Prudential financial advisors in Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.

NerdWallet maintains strict editorial guidelines to ensure coverage fairness and accuracy, allowing consumers to choose the policy that suits them best. It is essential to note that these carrier ratings are specific to auto insurance, and a company’s rating for other products may differ. For more information on how auto insurance companies are evaluated, please refer to NerdWallet’s criteria.

In terms of auto insurance coverage, Plymouth Rock offers standard options like comprehensive and collision coverage, rental reimbursement, and roadside assistance for drivers in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. The policy coverage also includes additional benefits like claim inspections, claim valet service, and the Get Home Safe program.

Depending on the package chosen, customers can access various perks such as additional rental coverage, personal property coverage, airbag benefits, and more. The Assurance Premier package includes additional features like deductible credits, trip interruption coverage, new car replacement, and gap insurance.

The pricing based on driving habits allows drivers to enroll in the Road Rewards telematics program, earning points for safe driving habits. Drivers can then redeem these points for rewards like gas, Amazon gift cards, and more, with no impact on their premiums.

While Plymouth Rock had complaints related to auto insurance, it was within the expected range according to data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Additionally, customers can access various services through Plymouth Rock’s website and mobile app, such as bill payment, claims filing, and policy updates.

Plymouth Rock also has partnerships with sports teams like the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, New England Patriots, and Boston Bruins, offering policyholders perks like discounted tickets and charitable donations for unsatisfied customers. Moreover, Plymouth Rock provides a variety of other insurances, including commercial auto insurance.

Discover an exclusive look into Plymouth Rock Insurance, a company that offers a unique approach to auto insurance coverage in specific states. Delve deeper into their comprehensive range of coverage options, including perks like on-demand claim inspections, claim valet service, and the innovative Get Home Safe program. Uncover the additional benefits that come with being a loyal customer, such as pet injury coverage and seat belt and airbag benefits. Explore the various packages Plymouth Rock offers, from Assurance Plus to Assurance Premier, each tailored to enhance your protection and peace of mind. Learn about the state-specific add-ons available and how Plymouth Rock rewards safe driving habits through their Road Rewards telematics program. Understand the customer satisfaction ratings and complaints data, offering valuable insights into their overall service quality. Unveil the unique partnerships Plymouth Rock has with renowned sports teams, providing exclusive benefits to policyholders. Experience the convenience of managing your insurance through their user-friendly website and mobile app. Lastly, discover the range of other insurance products Plymouth Rock offers, extending their exceptional coverage beyond just auto insurance. Follow along as we unravel the distinctive offerings of Plymouth Rock Insurance in this engaging exploration.

Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance Review 2024

In the fast-paced world of constantly evolving insurance options, finding the right provider can be a daunting task. With so many companies vying for your attention, it can be difficult to sift through the clutter and determine which one offers the best coverage at the most competitive rates. One company that has consistently stood out in the highly competitive auto insurance industry is Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance.

Founded in 1982, Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance has built a solid reputation for providing reliable coverage and excellent customer service to its policyholders. With a strong presence in the Northeastern United States, Plymouth Rock has become a trusted name in the industry, offering a wide range of auto insurance products to meet the diverse needs of drivers in the region.

Coverage Options

One of the key factors that sets Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance apart from its competitors is its diverse range of coverage options. Whether you’re looking for basic liability coverage to meet state requirements or comprehensive coverage to protect your vehicle against theft, vandalism, and natural disasters, Plymouth Rock has you covered. With customizable policies tailored to your specific needs, you can rest easy knowing that you have the right level of protection in place.

In addition to standard auto insurance coverage, Plymouth Rock also offers a variety of optional add-ons, such as roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and gap insurance. These additional features can provide added peace of mind and convenience in the event of an accident or breakdown, ensuring that you’re never left stranded or without a vehicle when you need it most.

Customer Service

Another standout feature of Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance is its commitment to exceptional customer service. With a team of dedicated agents and claims adjusters on hand to assist you every step of the way, you can count on Plymouth Rock to provide prompt and personalized attention whenever you need it. Whether you have questions about your policy, need help filing a claim, or simply want to update your coverage, the friendly and knowledgeable staff at Plymouth Rock are always ready to lend a helping hand.

Additionally, Plymouth Rock offers convenient online tools and resources to make managing your policy easier than ever. With a user-friendly website and mobile app, you can quickly access policy documents, make payments, and file claims from the comfort of your own home or on the go. This commitment to technology and innovation sets Plymouth Rock apart from traditional insurers, ensuring that you have the flexibility and convenience you need to stay connected and in control of your coverage.


While quality coverage and customer service are crucial factors to consider when choosing an auto insurance provider, affordability is also a key consideration for many drivers. Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance understands the importance of offering competitive rates without compromising on quality or service, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers.

By leveraging advanced data analytics and underwriting techniques, Plymouth Rock is able to offer personalized quotes based on individual risk factors and driving habits. This means that you can potentially save money on your premiums by demonstrating safe driving behavior and taking advantage of discounts for things like bundling policies, completing driving courses, or installing anti-theft devices in your vehicle.

Furthermore, Plymouth Rock offers flexible payment options to accommodate your budget and lifestyle. With convenient payment plans and discounts for paying in full or setting up automatic payments, you can choose the payment method that works best for you and enjoy peace of mind knowing that your coverage is always up to date.


In conclusion, Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance continues to impress customers with its comprehensive coverage options, exceptional customer service, and affordability. With a solid track record of reliability and satisfaction, Plymouth Rock has earned a loyal following among drivers in the Northeastern United States, making it a top choice for those seeking quality coverage at competitive rates.

If you’re in the market for auto insurance in 2024, consider giving Plymouth Rock a closer look. With its strong reputation, customizable policies, and commitment to customer satisfaction, Plymouth Rock may just be the right fit for your insurance needs. Contact Plymouth Rock today to request a quote and experience the difference for yourself.

Scroll to Top